Referral programmes are a standard marketing tool in many industries. Existing customers receive a reward for referring new customers, while the new customer may also be offered a voucher.
Stricter rules apply in the healthcare market. The Hamburg Higher Regional Court prohibited a referral campaign operated by a hearing aid provider under which both the existing customer and the newly referred customer were to receive a EUR 50 voucher.
The decision is relevant not only to hearing aid providers, but also to manufacturers, dealers and distributors of medical devices, pharmacies, healthcare platforms and providers of diagnostic or therapeutic services.
EUR 50 vouchers for existing and new customers
A nationwide chain of hearing aid retailers promoted a customer referral programme.
Under the programme, the referring customer and the newly referred customer each received a voucher worth EUR 50. To qualify, the new customer had to
- undergo a free hearing test; and
- if hearing loss was detected, trial an individually fitted hearing aid.
The vouchers could be used either for products sold by the hearing aid provider or at various partner shops.
The German Centre for Protection against Unfair Competition considered the campaign to involve prohibited promotional gifts under section 7(1) of the German Healthcare Advertising Act (Heilmittelwerbegesetz – HWG) and brought an action seeking injunctive relief.
The Hamburg Higher Regional Court upheld the claim.
Why the Healthcare Advertising Act applied
The HWG does not apply exclusively to medicinal products. It also covers advertising for medical devices and certain products, procedures and treatments intended to detect, eliminate or alleviate illnesses and physical disorders.
Hearing aids are medical devices within the meaning of the EU Medical Device Regulation. The advertised hearing test was also a diagnostic procedure intended to detect possible hearing loss.
The Court therefore held that the campaign fell within the scope of the HWG.
The fact that the hearing test was provided free of charge did not alter that conclusion. The HWG may also apply to advertising for diagnostic services offered without payment.
Product advertising or general corporate advertising?
The HWG generally applies to advertising relating to specific products or services. Pure corporate or image advertising, by contrast, does not automatically fall within its specific restrictions.
The distinction can be difficult in practice.
The Hamburg Higher Regional Court found a sufficient connection with specific products and services. The hearing test and the subsequent trial of an individually fitted hearing aid were necessary conditions for receiving the vouchers.
The campaign was therefore not limited to promoting the company in general. It was designed to direct potential customers into a particular diagnostic and sales process leading towards the supply of a hearing aid.
For companies, the conclusion is important: Labelling a campaign as image, service or referral advertising is not decisive. Its objective content, participation requirements and the specific customer journey created by the campaign will determine its legal classification.
Vouchers as prohibited promotional gifts
Section 7(1) HWG generally prohibits offering, announcing or granting benefits and other promotional gifts unless a statutory exception applies.
A promotional gift will normally exist where the recipient considers that they are receiving a monetary benefit free of charge. In the Court’s view, the EUR 50 vouchers constituted such a benefit.
The benefit must also create at least an abstract risk of improperly influencing the recipient.
In relation to new customers, the Court considered that the voucher could induce them to undergo a hearing test with the advertising company rather than consulting a doctor or another hearing aid provider.
The vouchers granted to existing customers were also problematic. Section 7 HWG is not limited to benefits received directly by the eventual purchaser of the medical device. A referral reward may improperly motivate an existing customer to direct another person to a particular provider.
Not automatically permissible as a price reduction
Section 7 HWG permits certain immediate price reductions and monetary discounts.
However, a voucher for a future transaction is not necessarily equivalent to an immediate reduction in the purchase price of the particular product being acquired. This is especially true where the voucher may also be redeemed with third parties.
Companies should therefore not assume that a reward expressed as a monetary amount will automatically qualify as a permissible cash discount. The specific structure of the promotion and its direct connection with the relevant purchase are decisive.
Relevance to medical device companies and distributors
The decision is not limited to hearing aid retailers. Comparable risks may arise in referral programmes involving
- spectacles and contact lenses;
- orthopaedic aids;
- dental products;
- digital health applications;
- diagnostic tests;
- aesthetic medical treatments;
- medical devices intended for home use; and
- other healthcare services.
Particular caution is required where eligibility for the reward depends on the new customer undergoing an examination, consultation, trial or fitting that will typically lead to the purchase of a medical device.
Three-party arrangements are also covered. The benefit does not have to be granted to the eventual purchaser. Rewards paid to introducers, relatives, existing customers or other third parties may also fall within section 7 HWG.
Consequences for marketing and compliance
Companies should conduct a legal review of referral and bonus programmes in the healthcare sector before publication. The review should address at least the following questions:
- Does the campaign relate to a particular medical device or healthcare service?
- What action must the customer take to receive the reward?
- Who receives the benefit?
- What is its financial value?
- Could it improperly influence the recipient’s choice?
- Is it genuinely an immediate price reduction?
- Does a statutory exception under section 7 HWG apply?
- Are the advertising copy, programme terms and actual implementation consistent?
Marketing agencies and distribution partners should also be included in the review. A commercially successful campaign may create substantial warning-letter, injunction and litigation risks if compliance with healthcare advertising law is considered only after the campaign has launched.
Conclusion
The Hamburg Higher Regional Court has set narrow limits for referral programmes involving medical devices. A EUR 50 voucher may constitute a prohibited promotional gift if it is intended to induce customers or intermediaries to initiate a particular diagnostic and sales process with a specific provider.
Companies should not assess such campaigns solely by reference to general marketing standards. Where medical devices or health-related examinations and treatments are involved, the specific requirements of the German Healthcare Advertising Act must also be considered.
Case reference: Hamburg Higher Regional Court, judgment of 5 February 2026 – 3 UKl 1/24.
Procedural status: According to the available publications, the judgment is not yet binding; proceedings concerning the decision are currently pending before the German Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof – BGH) under case no. I ZR 60/26.
This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice in any individual case.